Brittaney would love to make a custom cake for you! We also offer cheesecakes, cookies, pies, and more! Stop in, text or call to place your order.
Please reach out to us if you cannot find an answer to your question.
Q; How far in advance do I need to order?
A; We recommend ordering at least 72 hours (3 days) in advance for standard cakes, and 1 week in advance for custom designs, sugar cookies, or large cakes. A rush fee may apply for shorter notice.
Q; What size cakes do you offer?
A; We offer round cakes from 4" to 14", as well as 8", 10", or 12" squares, and quarter, half, or full size sheet cakes.
Q; What types of frosting do you offer?
A; Our standard frosting is Swiss meringue buttercream. We also offer ganache, cream cheese, and ermine frosting, as well as French, Italian meringue and American buttercream. Vegan and sugar-free frosting options are also available.
Q; Can you accommodate dietary restrictions?
A; Gluten-free, sugar-free, vegan, and allergen-free cake options may be available by special request. Please note that all items are made in a kitchen that handles wheat, dairy, nuts, eggs, and other allergens.
Q; How much do cakes cost?
A; Prices start at $30 for a basic 6" cake, and vary by flavor, size, and design. A custom quote will be provided after consultation.
Q; Do you require a deposit?
A; For cakes $100 or more, a non-refundable deposit of 50% is required to start your order. The remaining balance is due at pickup.
Q; What is your cancellation policy?
A; Cancellations must be made no less than 72 hours before your scheduled pickup time. Deposits are non-refundable, though store credit may be offered at owner discretion.
Q; Do you offer delivery?
A; We are currently pickup only, unless special arrangements are made for larger orders.
Q; How should I store my cake?
A; Cakes with dairy-based frosting should be stored under refrigeration; bring to room temp about an hour before serving for best flavor.
We recommend using the following guide of our most popular sizes to determine your cake size:
Cake Size 'Party' Slices 'Wedding' Slices
6" Round 8-12 12-16
8" Round 12-20 20-24
10" Round 20-30 30-38
1/4 Sheet 20-30 30-40
1/2 Sheet 40-60 60-80
Full Sheet 80-100 100-120
3968 East 42nd Street, Newburgh Heights, Ohio 44105, United States
Copyright © 2025 The Cinnful Whisk - All Rights Reserved.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.